The Indian-American voter, and rhe rise of anti-Indian attacks

Here is a snapshot of the Indian-American electorate: booming in size, and shifting towards the political center.  But also, with the rise of the Indian-American politician and with anti-immigrant policies of Trump,  it has reason to feeling targeted.

In 2024 about 2.6 million Indian-Americans were eligible to vote compared to 1.9 million in 2018. (These come from Carnegie Endowment for International Peace estimates.)  This implies an average annual increase of about 6% — far greater than the annual increase of Hispanics, and of course greater than that of white Americans, where the growth is flat to declining. Assuming continued growth of 6% in 2025 – 2026, that would bring us to about 2.9 million, roughly 1% of the entire eligible population. This fast growth is consistent with a demographic profile of a rapid increase of Indian immigrants from a small base in 2000 — with children born in the 2000s.

The Carnegie Endowment has been polling Indian Americans for some years. Here were a few key trends. Between 2020 and 2026 support for the Democratic Party declined from 52% to 46%. Support for the Republican Party grew from 15% to 19%. As for independent status: from 23% in 2020 to 29% in 2026.  Today, 53% self-identify as somewhere along the liberal spectrum, while only about 25% self-identify themselves as conservative. More are considering themselves moderate, now at 32%. Context: the total eligible population today is much more less liberal (liberal 28%, moderate 33%, conservative 35%).

Since 2024 younger American Indian-Americans, under the age 30, shifted towards Democrats whereas those over 50 years old moved in the opposite direction towards Republicans.  Young women are more Democratic than young men. The erosion of Democratic support is particularly strong among those without a college degree. Overall, political polarization by income level has strengthened.

Among reasons for not supporting the Republican Party, the overwhelming factor is a perception that the Republican Party is intolerant of minorities. This observation has grown quite a lot since 2024. Carnegie’s figures are not complete on this, but it may be that Indian-Americans may be more ready to say today than before that they have had negative experiences (it may be that younger persons are more ready to say this outloud).  As for reasons for not supporting the Democratic Party the outstanding one is the perception that the Democratic Party is weak on illegal immigration.

Inflation and jobs are uppermost in concern. Views in Trump immigration policy tend to track with moderate Americans – right with removing many, but opposed to very aggressive enforcement.

Anti-Indian sentiment

The Center for the Study of Organized Hate has studied a rise of factors which taken altogether evince an anti-South Asian sentiment.

One factor is White House policy which directly and adversely impacts Indians in ways greater than other nationalities. “A number of administration policies, particularly those related to the H-1B visa program, have disproportionately impacted South Asians who account for the majority of H-1B visa holders and constitute the single largest group of overseas students in the US. Members of the Trump administration have long been opposed to the visa program, with some like Stephen Miller accusing India of “cheating on immigration policies.”

Another factor is the rise of Indian-Americans in politics. They have become more visible — Kamala Harris, Usha Vance, Kash Patel, Zohran Mamdani, Pramila Jayapal, Ro Khanna, Vivek Ramaswamy, and others.

“The outpouring of anti-Indian hate on X61 in January 2025 was a response to an X post by Ramaswamy, in which he unfavorably contrasted mainstream American parenting culture with Indian-American parenting practices. It was also driven62 by a response to a post by Krishnan,63 in which he called for reforms to ease pathways for obtaining H-1B visas and green cards. Mamdani’s victory in the Democratic primary in June 2025 elicited an outpouring of Islamophobia as well as anti-South Asian hate targeting his Indian heritage, immigrant background, and racial identity. These attacks became more pronounced64 following his victory in the mayoral election in November 2025.”

 

Three things about the Hispanic vote

First, Hispanic political polling has reverted towards the pre-Trump era, but perhaps not completely. Here is my timeline of Hispanic national voting starting in 2016. Prior to Trump, 25%-30% of Hispanics voted Republican. In the 2024 election, close to 50% voted for Trump. At this time (mid September) about 30%-35% approve of Trump. Here is Salazar’s statement on September 17 plus links to her immigration reform Dignity Act, which is going nowhere, while an indication of how Republican frames normalization of unauthorized status.

Second, Hispanic Republican congress persons are experiencing whiplash, best seen with Congresswoman Salazar. She has reverted to accusing the administration of betraying Hispanics. Here is a profile on how Salazar in 2025 came out to support Venezuelans on TPS. She is the most visibly active of Hispanic Republican congresspersons in questioning the administration, if not outright defying it.

Third, the number of eligible Hispanic voters is inexorably rising but their voting proclivity is less, thereby blunting their impact in elections.

Between 2020 and 2024, The number of eligible Hispanic voters, which were 32 million or 13.5% of all eligible voters, rose to 36 million.  This year, 2029, eligible Hispanic voters are 39 million or 16% of all eligible voters. All the increase in eligible voters have been non-white (Hispanic, Black and Asian).  Eligible white voters remain about the same as in 2020. (Go here.) The white share of eligible voters declined from about 82% in 2000 to about 62% in 2026. But since whites turn out to vote a lot more than other groups, its actual diminishment in electoral impact has not declined as much.

Hispanics, indeed, turn out to vote much less than whites. In 2020, 73% of eligible white voters voted, compared to 53% of eligible Hispanic voters. (Go here.) In 2024, 71% of non-Hispanic white eligible voters voted, compared to 51% of Hispanic voters. (The percentages for Blacks 60% and Asians 57%.)

 

 

 

 

Poll on immigration, Texas turns problematic

In an early August poll, 93% of MAGA people approve of the Trump administration’s immigration policies. 85% of conservatives, 35% of moderates, and 4% of liberals do. Overall, 40% do.

Politico reports that Trump at the convention Sept 9 – 10 will praise the virtual closing of the Mexican border to asylum and other seekers and the continuing construction of a border wall. But “hardline immigration activists [are] already livid over their feeling that the administration hasn’t lived up to its campaign promises….it also is an acknowledgment that the politics of immigration are far thornier for Trump than they were at the 2024 convention when “MASS DEPORTATION NOW” signs filled the room. The change is due, in large part, to the killings in Minneapolis and Maine, third-country removals, and the arrests of thousands of long-term immigrants who have not committed violent crimes.”

“In Texas, Concerns [about deportations] were the central focus of a White House meeting …. between chief of staff Susie Wiles, Speaker Mike Johnson, and a group of Republican lawmakers….The group talked about growing concerns that Hispanic voters are abandoning the Republican Party in droves, as well as the policies driving these losses — immigration and affordability concerns. (Go here).

“Rep. Monica De La Cruz (R-Texas) was among the lawmakers in attendance….She, alongside South Texas leaders, held two additional meetings….one with Johnson and another with the White House Office of Legislative Affairs, to discuss her proposals for new policies to address worker shortages, including legislation to streamline visa programs and address the need for workers in the agriculture and construction industries.”

In 2024 and 2025, Cruz vocally supported Trump’s immigration policy. She has since become equivocal.  She is one of six Republican Congresspersons with an Hispanic majority population.

March, 2026, ICE detained the Gámez-Cuéllar family, including McAllen High School mariachi students whose asylum case was pending. De La Cruz called the detention “troubling,” contacted the White House, border czar Tom Homan and DHS officials, and helped obtain the release of 18-year-old Antonio Gámez-Cuéllar. She said, “We can have safe communities, and we can also have common-sense enforcement policies.”

 

 

 

 

An important analysis of the immigrant vote in November

Brookings released a well-documented study of how naturalized immigrants have been voting and specifically how they voted in November. Bottom line: Harris won their vote, but not by much overall. Here are some excerpts:

The proclivity to vote:

Foreign-born Asian and Latino groups vote at higher rates than their U.S.-born ethnic counterparts. Black immigrants vote at similar levels while white immigrants participate at lesser rates compared to U.S.-born whites. Yet, in recent years, the foreign-born population appears to be a much more politically engaged cohort, demonstrating above-average levels of voter enthusiasm with turnout exceeding the general electorate. National-level polling conducted between August 16 and August 28, 2024, prior to the election, showed that roughly 97% of naturalized citizens were “definitely or probably going to vote” in the 2024 election. This is above 2020 election levels, where 86.8% of respondents cast their vote, exceeding the nearly 66% of the total electorate—the highest rate since 1900.

How they voted:

Among those who would certainly vote, the polling found they favored Kamala Harris over Trump (by approximately 55% to 41%), both nationally and with some slight variation across key swing states. Similar to the general electorate, high cost of living/inflation ranked as the top issue with immigration following closely behind. Interestingly, on social values issues, foreign-born migrants are almost twice as likely to hold conservative/very conservative views and still identify as a Democrat compared to the overall population. This is further underscored with religious views—overall, immigrant evangelicals identify less with the Republican Party compared to U.S.-born evangelicals and young individuals (ages 18 to 29) are found to be more religious and conservative on social issues than their U.S.-born counterparts.

The Latino vote:

Within the Latino base, Harris secured a majority of all Latino voters (52% to 46%), However, Trump made significant gains—largely driven by the economic anxieties of Latino men. Notching a 10-point advantage with Latino men (54% to 44%), he overcame a roughly 23-point deficit to Biden just four years prior (59% to 36%). Still, while migrants favored Harris (by a seven-point margin) and also favored a path to citizenship for undocumented immigrants (by an eight-point margin), compared to the overall Latino electorate, they still appear to hold somewhat similar views to U.S.-born Latinos. Despite having been subjects of anti-immigrant language by Trump, polling finds that a majority of both U.S.-born (67%) and foreign-born Latino voters (51%) do not feel that the president-elect is referring to them.(Note: I have addressed the low turnout of Hispanics, which belies their growth in numbers, here).

 

 

Latino resentment about surge of temporary immigrants

Propublica reports, “Across the U.S., Latino immigrants who’ve been in the country a long time felt that asylum-seekers got preferential treatment. “Those of us who have been here for years get nothing,” said one woman from Mexico who has lived in Wisconsin for decades.

“ProPublica interviewed dozens of long-established Latino immigrants and their U.S.-born relatives in cities like Denver and Chicago and in small towns along the Texas border. Over and over, they spoke of feeling resentment as they watched the government ease the transition of large numbers of asylum-seekers into the U.S. by giving them access to work permits and IDs, and in some cities spending millions of dollars to provide them with food and shelter.”

The report summarizes well the problem which the Biden administration created:

In the months leading up to the presidential election, numerous polls picked up on the kinds of frustrations felt by Rosa and her family. Those polls indicated that many voters considered immigration one of the most pressing challenges facing the country and that they were disappointed in the Biden administration’s record.

Biden had come into office in 2021 promising a more humane approach to immigration after four years of more restrictive policies during the first Trump administration. But record numbers of immigrants who were apprehended at the U.S.-Mexico border began to overwhelm the system. While the Biden administration avoided talking about the border situation like a crisis, the way Trump and the GOP had, outspoken critics like Republican Texas Gov. Greg Abbott amplified the message that things at the border were out of control while he arranged to bus thousands of immigrants to Democrat-controlled big cities around the country. In Whitewater, hundreds of Nicaraguans arrived on their own to fill jobs in local factories, and many of them drove to work without licenses, putting a strain on the small local police department with only one Spanish-speaking officer.

While the Biden administration kept a Trump expulsion policy in place for three years, it also created temporary parole programs and an app to allow asylum-seekers to make appointments to cross the border. The result was that hundreds of thousands more immigrants were allowed to come into the country and apply for work permits, but the efforts didn’t assuage the administration’s critics on the right or left.

 

Hispanics turned to Trump

Texas’s most Hispanic county, Starr County, voted 57.7% for Trump vs. 41.8% for Harris. 97% of the populations self-identifies as Hispanic. The last time it voted Republican was in 1892.

Lawrence, MA, has the highest concentration of Hispanic persons in the state, at 82% of the city’s population.  Trump received 14% of the vote in 2016, 25% in 2020, and 40% in 2024 (go here.)

Nationwide, per exit polls, Trump won 46% of the Latino vote, up from 32% in 2020. It was the highest share for a Republican presidential candidate in at least 50 years, according to the Boston Globe.

There is a strong trend of greater numbers of Hispanic eligible voters contrasted with a flat or even declining number of white voters. But because Hispanic voting propensity (about 50% of eligible voters)  is much lower than that of whites (about 70%), the power of Hispanics at the voting booth is less than it could be. (Go here and here).

The Lichtman test and the Trump victory

Allan Lichtman had a run of predicting correctly (with some fudging) presidential elections since 1980 with his 13 keys to the White House. In media interviews and profiles, in September he confidently predicted that Harris would win. Why did he get it wrong?

Since January 2024 I analyzed his 13 keys, scoring them to predict the winner. In mid October I decided that Trump would win. Lichtman mis-scored his own test.

As of mid October, 10 of the 13 keys had been resolved, resulting in an incomplete score of 6 for Harris and 4 four Trump. In order for Trump to win, he had to win each of the remaining three tests. Here are these tests. Trump won all three tests, resulting in a final score of Trump 7, Harris 6.

Key #10. Foreign or military failure: There is no major failure during the term comparable to Pearl Harbor or the Iran hostage crisis that appears to significantly undermine America’s national interests or threaten its standing in the world.  Biden’s management of the border crisis constituted a foreign policy failure in that the surge of migrants into the country (amnesty applicants, humanitarian parole and Temporary Protected Status) was viewed as a non-military invasion, made visible by shelter crises, over-stressed public schools, and by the illusion of higher crime rates. The White House never tried to explain to the public what its policy was. In reality, it had no coherent policy.

Key #6. Long-term economy: Real per-capita economic growth during the term equals or exceeds the mean growth during the previous two terms. Even with technically higher GDP per capita growth, most people felt worse off during the Biden administration, primarily due to inflation.

Key #7. Policy change: The administration achieves a major policy change during the term comparable to the New Deal or the first-term Reagan Revolution. Lichtman in interviews firmly said yes. But Biden’s three major economic development bills, The Inflation Reduction Act, the CHIPS Act, and an infrastructure act were poorly promoted and explained by the White House. Most voters likely could not recall them if asked.

Allan Lichtman’s presidential race “keys” and immigration

Since January, I have followed the Allan Lichtman tests (“keys”) for the 2024 presidential election.  Immigration figures in this year!

The test is basically a vote of confidence or no confidence in the incumbent party. The candidate who gets at least 7 out of 13 tests wins the election (it is ambiguous whether popular vote or electoral college vote). The test was developed by statistical analysis of many presidential elections; the 13 questions when taken together have had a very tight fit with election results. They have proven right since the 1980 election (with some fudging in 2000 and 2016).

Lichtman himself said in September that Harris is sure to win.  In my view, her victory per the Lichtman test is not at all assured, and immigration comes in as a factor.

At this time (November 1), seven tests are resolved, 4 for Harris (#2,4,5 and 9) and 3 for Trump (#1,3 and 12). Three tests are probably resolved, 2 for Harris (8 and 13) and 1 for Trump (11). This sums to 6 for Harris and 4 for Trump. There remain 3 more tests. If Harris wins just one, she will have a total of 7 tests going her way. Trump has to win all three.

10.Foreign or military failure: “There is no major failure during the term comparable to Pearl Harbor or the Iran hostage crisis that appears to significantly undermine America’s national interests or threaten its standing in the world.”  Biden’s track record on the border, which metastasized into crowding of shelters and public schools across the U.S., might will be consider a “major failure.”

The two remaining unresolved tests are:

6.Long-term economy: Real per-capita economic growth during the term equals or exceeds the mean growth during the previous two terms.  The Gallup Poll reports that 61% of Americans believe they are worse off than in the past.

7.Policy change: The administration achieves a major policy change during the term comparable to the New Deal or the first-term Reagan Revolution.  Lichtman believes that the three legislative packages of Biden constitute such a major policy change. The problem is that most people cannot identify them or see how they have been directly impacted by them in a positive way.

 

 

 

Most Repulicans say that immigrants “poison the blood” of Americans

PRRI did a poll covering a number of issues but featured immigration. It wrote in summary, “American attitudes about immigration policies have grown more conservative; nationally, those trends are driven primarily by Republicans and independents adopting more conservative views in recent years.”

the poll results showed that 34%  of Americans  say that immigrants entering the country illegally today are “poisoning the blood of our country,” including 61% of Republicans, 30% of independents, and 13% of Democrats. White evangelical Protestants (60%) are the only religious group among whom a majority agree that immigrants entering the country illegally are poisoning the blood of the country.

Donald Trump said that immigrants are  “poisoning the blood of our country” on October 4, 2023, during a rally in New Hampshire.

Other instances of using the phrase “poisoning the blood” of a selected and protected native population are:

Nazi Germany: Joseph Goebbels, Hitler’s Minister of Propaganda, frequently spoke of “Jewish blood” as a “poison” to German society, aiming to stoke antisemitic fervor.

United States: During the early 20th Century decades, Madison Grant, an influential American eugenicist, advocated for racial purity, saying that immigration from Eastern and Southern Europe would “contaminate” or “poison” the American stock. His 1916 book, The Passing of the Great Race, became a significant influence on immigration restrictions in the U.S., especially the Immigration Act of 1924.

South Africa: Politicians like Dr. Hendrik Verwoerd, a leading architect of apartheid, said such racial mixing was dangerous to the “racial health” of South Africans.

Hungary: Viktor Orbán, Hungary’s Prime Minister, has used rhetoric about preserving “Hungarian blood” and protecting the country from the “infiltration” of migrants, framing immigration as a threat to Hungary’s ethnic and cultural fabric.

Ronald Brownstein documents Trump’s steep descent in zeno-phobia

Ronald Brownstein’s new article in the Atlantic highlights the escalating intensity of Donald Trump’s anti-immigrant rhetoric during his current campaign. “Even by his standards, the volume and venom of Trump’s attacks on immigrants have amped up sharply during this campaign.” Trump’s immigrant rhetoric is increasingly extreme and detached from factual reality.

Trump and J.D. Vance have made numerous claims about immigrants, including accusations of job theft, crime increases, housing cost inflation, disease spread, voter fraud, and resource depletion. Brownstein systematically debunks these claims, citing data and local records that contradict the candidates’ assertions. For instance, violent crime rates have been declining, and research suggests undocumented immigrants commit fewer offenses than native-born Americans. Employment data also refutes claims about job theft, showing significant job growth among native-born Americans.

He expresses particular concern over Trump’s dehumanizing language towards immigrants, noting his use of terms like “poisoning the blood” and referring to them as “animals” or not even “people.” The article draws parallels between this rhetoric and historical instances of dangerous xenophobia. A 1917 anti-immigration screed by James Murphy Ward even referred to immigrants (in this instance Chinese) making soup out of rats

Brownstein notes that Trump’s recent on genetics and murder suggest a turn towards eugenics in his campaign messaging.