Can ICE be sued? The case of Renee Good

One of the most unsettling features of the administration’s in-your-face deportation initiatives was the killing of Renee Good on January 7, 2026, in Minneapolis by Jonathon Ross, an ICE officer. To date, there is no report on any federal investigation of her killing by Ross. On October 1, her family sued the federal government and individuals, and included a suit under Minnesota law.

The signal greatest challenge for the plaintiffs relating to the federal government is that of Federal immunity.  This challenge would appear in other suits against ICE personnel.

The plaintiffs primarily cite two laws: the Federal Tort Claims Act and the Ku Klux Klan Act of 1871.  The challenge is to show that a conspiracy existed and that Ross’ actions were more than reckless and excessive force.  Federal employees are immunized from civil suited by the Westfall Act enacted in 1988.

What about the Chauvin case?

Derek Chauvin was convicted for the killing of George Floyd as a local public employee.  Chauvin was an officer in the Minneapolis Police Department. On April 20, 2021 a jury in Minnesota state court, convicted him.  The Justice Department separately prosecuted Chauvin for willfully violating Floyd’s constitutional rights under 18 U.S.C. §242. He pleaded guilty on December 15, 2021. Ross, a federal employee, is covered by a federal law – the Westfall Act.

 

 

 

Among those charged by DOJ for illegal voting is a 72 yo grandfather of 10 citizens

Omar Alexander Muñoz, a 72-year-old Belizean citizen living in Commerce, Los Angeles County is one of the 11 persons arrested among the 28 persons charged by the DOJ for illegal voting. Federal agents arrested Munoz on October 19. He is a lawful permanent resident.   The DOJ says that he registered to vote in September 2019, claiming U.S. citizenship, and voted in four elections: one in 2020, two in 2022, and one in 2024.

According to his wife, he is a Trump supporter. The couple have three children and 10 grandchildren, all of whom are U.S. citizens.

The AP reports: “Dozens of federal agents descended on Omar Alexander Muñoz’s residential cul-de-sac in Commerce, a small city in Los Angeles County, to make the arrest. Muñoz was put in handcuffs in his pajamas and taken into federal custody downtown.

Esmeralda Muñoz, 70, said her family was furious that agents showed up to their home in full tactical gear with guns drawn to arrest her husband before dawn. “It’s a show for them,” she said, calling it a “shame” that government officials arrived with camera crews and news helicopters.”

The arrests are being heavily reported in the Spanish language media.

How a federal executive was defamed over immigration by the Trump Administration

The case of Mary Comans, a fired FEMA executive, is an example of the recklessness of the Trump administration’s strategy to demonize people and organization over immigration. On October 13,2026 a federal judge ruled that Comans was fired in early 2025 and maligned knowingly by the administration, Elon Musk and Laura Loomer.  Mary Coman’s name is cleared. But her chances of winning a defamation suit are apparently slight. Federal employees have strong immunity even with deliberate wrong-doing, and statutes of limitations come in.

Background: Mary Comans began federal service in 2004, joined FEMA’s Senior Executive Service in 2016, and was selected as permanent Chief Financial Officer in December 2017. She supervised approximately 450 employees and administered FEMA’s $45 billion budget. She did not select grant recipients, establish grant criteria, or make binding policy. Her superiors could override her decisions. She received a perfect rating on her final performance review.

Here is a timeline of her persecution.

January 20, 2025: President Trump signs an executive order pausing federal funding to nongovernmental organizations providing services to illegal or removable aliens.

Late January – early February: confusion in the administration whether FEMA can suspend per the executive order grants to state and local governments associated with accommodating migrants in New York City hotels. The amount of the grants in question were never confirmed but may have been about $60 million. Some DOGE employers embedded in the Treasury Dept assert the grants are illegal.  Comans and three other career officials are blamed.

February 11, 2025: Comans is fired without cause or explanation. The sole justification given is the President’s asserted absolute authority to dismiss her. DHS issued a press release accusing Comans of circumventing leadership and making unauthorized payments for luxury hotels for migrants. DHS officials publicly accused her of unauthorized migrant-hotel payments, laundering prohibited funding, and concealing information from counsel. Musk published her photograph alongside an accusation of criminal conduct. These start the statements which the judge in October 2026 found that the officials knew were false.

Kristi Noem and Corey Lewandowski provided blogger Laura Loomer with false allegations that Comans illegally funded more than $59 million in hotel accommodation in violation of Trump’s order. Loomer published them on X.

July  24, 2025: Comans files suit. Case: Mary Comans v. Executive Office of the President, Department of Homeland Security, and United States of America. The case was heard in the summer of 2026  in the  District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia Division by Michael S. Nachmanoff.

July 21, 2026: Nachmanoff held that Comans’s dismissal deprived her of her protected employment interest without due process. The court also finds that the defamatory statements deprived her of her liberty interest in her good name and refers the matter for a name-clearing hearing.

October 13, 2026: Mary Comans v. Executive Office of the President, Department of Homeland Security, and United States of America, was heard in the Eastern District of Virginia by Judge William E. Fitzpatrick The order is dated October 13, 2026. The judge wrote that based on facts the government did not contest, senior officials conducted a coordinated campaign falsely accusing Comans of illegally funding migrant hotels, laundering money, and disobeying presidential orders. He found that Musk, Noem, Lewandowski, and other officials knew relevant accusations were false. Agency leadership and DOGE personnel had actually approved continued payments to state and local governments in the weeks before Coman’s dismissal. He characterized Musk’s publication of her photograph alongside a criminal accusation as intimidation. It adjudged her name cleared concerning her FEMA conduct. He did not award damages or determine individual defamation liability.

Trump’s Hail Mary effort to interfere with elections

The DOJ today (10/15/26) sued the state of California over what it alleged were 20,000 non-citizens on voting lists in the state.  It makes the assertion without access to the state’s voter lists.

On August 18 the administration asserted that 24,000 non-citizens voted in 2020. It is now asserting that about that number of non-citizens are ready to vote in one state.

Today’s suit comes after two key court defeats by the Trump administration, and weeks after an allegation of 15,903 non-citizens on Nevada’s voting list was cut to zero. The suit comes weeks after a whistleblower’s allegations were disclosed about improper federal efforts to challenge state voting lists. It comes three months after it alleged on July 17 that there may be as many as 190,832 non-citizens on California’s voter list

How the courts took away DOJ’s two major weapons

Federal courts have denied the Trump administration power to demand voter lists from states and denied it power to take alleged non-citizen voters to court. These decisions removed the most direct means of the administration to cause havoc in the November 2026 elections.  The administration’s blocked actions, in the context of overwhelming evidence that non-citizens are not on voting lists except perhaps in trace amounts, were to flood the media with lurid allegations before an election. Proving the allegations was basically irrelevant.

The Trump administration is counting on allegations not being proved wrong until after November.

It takes time to prove these allegations wrong.  It took two months (July 2026 – Sept. 2026) from when DHS told Nevada there might be 15,903 noncitizens registered to vote, then reduced the number to 185. Nevada responded that its records indicated all 185 were citizens.

Whose voter database is being used by the administration?

A League of Women Voter’s suit filed also today – 10/15/26 –alleges that an ICE unit called Homeland Security Investigations is in charge of collecting and analyzing voting databases provided by commercial firms. The suit cites LexisNexis and its product Accurint.

 

Hispanic Catholic support of Trump at 18%

Per a Pew Research poll, Hispanic Catholic support of Trump went from 31% in January 2025 to 18% in October 2026.  White Catholic support declined from 59% to 39%. About one third of self-described Catholics in the United States are Hispanic.

Late September polls on immigration

September polling (Politico and WSJ) shows broad multi-party support for stopping illegal migration, and Republicans as a whole say that immigration as a whole has not had a positive effect. But when unauthorized persons who have not broken laws become the focus, even Republicans swing towards accepting their presence.  This apparent confusion among Republican reflects a long-standing median view across the political spectrum that is comfortable with immigrants including those unauthorized to keep the country moving. Inherent in the median mindset is a tortured logic of “I like immigrants, just not so many, and laws must be enforced.”

The media has been adverse / brutal to mass deportation. Minneapolis has had a lasting effect. The Spanish language media is reporting heart-breaking stories.

From Politico:

MAGA advocates have a tougher line on immigration  on some issues than other Trump voters.

“Border should be fully closed” MAGA 55% Other Trump voters 40%”BUT “Immigration has an overall positive effect” MAGA 29% other Trump voters 41%

On the other hand, there is little support for  deporting“People living in the U.S. for several years without legal status” MAGA 17% other Trump voters 41%.

And, “Both MAGA and non-MAGA Trump voters are open to maintaining or increasing the number of people coming into the U.S. to work in sectors facing labor shortages, such as health care or agriculture. Sixty-five percent of MAGA Trump voters and 69% non-MAGA Trump voters say they want to see about the same number — or more — people coming to the U.S. to work in those sectors facing labor shortages.”

From a Wall Street Journal late September poll:

“Create a pathway to citizenship for long-term immigrants who contribute to their communities:” Democrats 97% Republicans  54% independents 69%.

 

600,000 foreign born persons lose Medicaid coverage today, 10/1/26

Today, October 1, 2026, roughly 600,000 foreign-born persons without a green card lose Medicaid coverage, and will rely from now on primarily for free care services such as in federally-funded community care centers and hospitals. This is a rough estimate, an extrapolation from a handful of state-specific estimates.  (I draw on here, here and elsewhere for this posting.)

The cutbacks would be much higher except that Cubans and Haitians who are covered by the legal statuses addressed are exempted. Due to the frustrating failure of the government to provide counts of persons accounted for by immigrant status,  I cannot estimate how many Cubans and Haitians avoid the cutbacks. It could be several hundred thousands.

In 2021, the Migration Policy Institute wrote that as of 2019, 9.5 million foreign-born persons (out of a total then of about 45 million) were in economic conditions associated with eligibility for Medicaid, but about half were ineligible, either because they were unauthorized or due to some previously established rule applying to immigrants. After the time of the report, millions of persons came to the U.S., many with conditional legal status.  If one takes these rough estimates into account, perhaps a million – couple of million foreign born persons in the country were as of September 30,2026 eligible for Medicaid – this is a crude guess.

Without knowing the specific conditions of legal presence one cannot say if a person – Afghan, Venezuelan,  etc. – is affected. It is almost as if the blow falls differently door by door.

Below is a summary of the major categories – not all – affected.

The refugees, people granted asylum, and humanitarian parolees losing Medicaid coverage beginning October 1, 2026, are people legally present in the United States who previously qualified for coverage but have not obtained green cards or another status that preserves eligibility. They generally have low incomes and meet their state’s other Medicaid requirements. Some will retain coverage through exceptions for children and pregnant people or through state-funded programs.

Refugees. Those still holding refugee status without permanent residency will lose ordinary federally funded Medicaid unless an exception applies.

People granted asylum.  They may already have lived here for years while their cases were considered. The affected group consists of people whose asylum has been granted but who have not yet become permanent residents. A pending asylum application alone generally did not establish eligibility for ordinary federal Medicaid.

Humanitarian parolees. Humanitarian parole itself provides temporary permission to remain, rather than permanent residency.

Conditions for ICE detainees at 26 Federal Plaza in New York City

ICE has temporary holding rooms in New York City at 26 Federal Plaza, a federal office building. The location is intended for brief custody, generally 12 hours or less, while people are processed or transferred to a detention facility. The rooms have no beds, cots, showers, or windows.

In Sergio Alberto Barco Mercado v. Markwayne Mullin, et al., Judge Lewis A. Kaplan of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York ruled on September 24 that even after temporary orders improved conditions, ICE exceeded room capacities, failed to provide confidential legal calls and used other floors to hold detainees contrary to the court’s orders.

Page 108 of the opinion:

“The conditions of confinement to which ICE subjected immigration detainees at 26 Fed during the summer of 2025 were inhumane and unconstitutional. By detaining far more persons in the hold rooms than ever was intended and for far longer than ever was intended, ICE objectively deprived detainees of sleep, sanitary living conditions, basic personal hygiene needs, sufficient food and water, and adequate medical care. ICE prevented detainees from accessing counsel, who might have stood in the way of what it was doing. Some of these deprivations impacted detainees immediately; others only after longer periods. ICE knew, or should have known, that how it was treating detainees was wrong, yet it continued to do it anyway. It did so to inflict punishment on detainees and induce them to self-deport. The [Temporary Restraining Order] and [Preliminary Injuction of Sept 17, 2025] abated ICE’s constitutional violations, but ICE’s ongoing noncompliance and the cognizable danger that it, amid rising immigration arrests, again will use 26 Fed as the “give” in the system prove that a permanent fix is needed to protect the Constitution against the administration’s mass deportation program.”

Third country deportations

A Washington Post-participated investigation report says that the Trump administration pledged at least $410 million to secure third-country deportation arrangements with 31 countries, mostly in Africa and Latin America. A State Department Office of Remigration, led by Christian Ehrhardt, runs the program. More than 25,000 people have been sent to at least 28 third countries.  Nominally the program is for deportations of persons whose home countries refuse to accept. Most of the deportations have been to Latin American countries, many Mexico.  Costa Rica accepted migrants from China, Russia, Iran, and Afghanistan.

The African countries which are or are currently negotiating to accept deportations are Democratic Republic of the Congo, Equatorial Guinea, Eswatini, South Sudan, Central African Republic, Ghana, Sierra Leone, Uganda, Togo, Guinea-Bissau, and Gabon. One instance: Liberia received a deportation flight, but the six migrants refused to leave the aircraft and were rerouted to Equatorial Guinea.

The reporting team assembled the 25,000 figure from estimates, including few specific data sources (for instance, Human Rights Watch counted 12,977 third-country nationals sent to Mexico between January 2025 and March 2026).

The article mentions without going into much depth of detail how third party deportations to Africa are designed to frighten unauthorized persons into their self-deporting to their home country. The Abrego Garcia case (covered in other posts): His lawyers allege that prosecutors offered him a guilty plea followed by deportation to comparatively safer, Spanish-speaking Costa Rica, while threatening deportation to Uganda if he refused.

How the story was sourced.” The Washington Post writes it is part of a project involving  “72 journalists, 26 news organizations, 15 countries: a global investigation into the Trump administration’s secret deals to expel people worldwide.”

The Migration Policy Institute in January 2026 published a study of “externalization,” which puts the administration’s third-party deportation policy in global context. Europe and Australia have externalization policies as well was the U.S. they include:

Preventing migrants from reaching destination countries, for example, EU cooperation with Libya and Tunisia and U.S. cooperation with Mexico.

Return hubs. Rejected asylum seekers are transferred to facilities in third countries while authorities arrange return, settlement or further movement. The EU authorized this approach in 2026.

External legal-pathway screening. The Biden administration’s Safe Mobility Offices in Latin America was this approach –killed by the Trump administration.

More on the administration’s campaign on illegal voters

This posting follows up with September 14 developments on Trump’s campaign on illegal voters. In sum, the administration is surrepiciously implementing its real plan. Unburdened by evidence of non-voting eligible people on voting rolls of more than a few hundred in a state, the Trump administration continues to work this issue.

Yesterday, in United States Postal Service v California, the Supreme Court 7-2 dealt a death blow to what I call the Postal Service plan for this November, without a majority opinion but with one concurring and two dissenting (Alioto and Thomas) opinions. The apparent rationale is that to apply the plan would at this time impose an intolerable burden on state and local officials. This leaves what I call the Postal Serbice  plan basically viable for 2028.

The administration’s legal argument comes to this: State and local election systems can set their own rules but do not have the authority to set rules for how the Postal Service oversees the delivery of mail – by content, envelop design, address management, etc. the Postal Service has been granted wide discretion. Were there no last-minute controversy, the case (again, United States Postal Service v California) might have swung in favor of the administration.

In my recent post, ”Trump’s real plan to control state and local voting,”  I lay out what I think is the real administration’s strategy, which is to apply its own databases against state voter lists and to reject matches that appear to show a non-citizen on a voter list. I noted the quality control and other issues involved.

Alabama has undertaken to so this voluntarily, resulting in 184 findings out of a population of three million.

On the same day (Sept 14) of the Supreme Court decision, Senator Alex Padill, and Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) announced the receipt of a new whistleblower disclosure they received on September 8. The whistleblower disclosed that over the past month or so DHS and USCIS have been inspecting state voting list directly, using their own staffs and applying undisclosed methods.   This is an effort to apply the administration’s strategy presumably to come up with hair-raising accounts of how a Syrian suicide bomber has voted repeatedly.

DHS launched an “Unlawful Voter Initiative” in August 2026 to look for noncitizens who had registered or voted. It assigned hundreds of employees from U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services’ Fraud Detection and National Security Directorate to the effort. On August 21, they were told to watch a training video lasting about an hour and 45 minutes. By August 25, they were reviewing names supplied by DHS. The stated target was 40 cases per employee per day, or roughly 12 minutes per person, with the rushed review to be completed by September 12.

DHS supplied data suggesting that particular people might be unlawful voters. Some of that data reportedly came from its SAVE immigration-status system (see my prior post.)

Officers then compared federal data about a person’s citizenship and immigration history with state voter records. To retrieve individual records from state websites, they (per the whistleblower) entered identifying details such as birth dates or partial Social Security numbers and, where required, claimed to be the voter or to have the voter’s permission. The whistleblower says those claims were false and may have violated state laws governing access to voter information.

Officers were then instructed to create a record in the federal “TEC” law enforcement database, a shared repository for suspected persons. These records were to be identified as “unlawful voters.”  This despite the often – shown problems in searching for non-voters due to inconsistent, out of date, mistakenly matched records.

In all of this, why to bureaucrats go along with the idee fixe that there are loads of illegal voters? The bureaucratic mentality after years of experience boils down to perfectly applying orders from above.