NPR story of a new illegal immigrant returned to El Salvador
National Public Radio's Morning Edition is running a two part series on the impact of immigration law enforcement on immigrant households. The first of the series was aired on April 7, describing the devastating effect of Julio Cuellar’s return to El Salvador after being caught by the Feds shortly after being taken across the border by a coyote. The story reveals the desperate situation of poor households in Latin America.
On another radio new broadcast, I heard an immigration expert say that despite the recession most or all of illegal workers will stay in the U.S. Even one day of work at $60 as a day laborer yields as much income for an entire month back in Mexico. That’s shows you how important it is for workers to get into and stay in the U.S.
the transcript:
As the U.S. intensified its illegal immigration crackdown in recent years, deportations to El Salvador increased dramatically. Last year, according to El Salvador's immigration ministry, 20,000 Salvadorans were sent back home from the U.S., compared to 3,500 who were deported in 2004.
On a recent blazing hot afternoon, security guards escorted 33 men and nine women from the tarmac at Cuscatlan International Airport in San Salvador into a cramped processing room.
Some deportees look defiant. Others look destroyed and lost. But they all seem to brighten as they file into rows of plastic chairs and find on each one a warm pupusa — the thick tortilla that is El Salvador's national dish. Officials try to bolster the group with speeches welcoming them home.
"Thank God you are here and in much better shape than many others," a police officer tells them. "Some return wounded or dead. But you are very much alive, ready to set off on your next trip if you choose!"
Quiet laughter fills the room as the deportees nod and cheer. Some say they do plan to go back to the U.S. as soon as possible. With few prospects in El Salvador and family still in America, they say they have nothing to lose.
But not Julio Cuellar.
In a small room, 45-year-old Cuellar gives a migration official his personal details.
Cuellar tells a government official that three months earlier, he abandoned his job as a state policeman to go to the U.S.
When the woman asks what he is going to do now that he's back in El Salvador, Cuellar pauses before responding.
"Well, I need to go to my house and talk with my family," Cuellar says. "More than anything, I need to explain the experience I've lived through."
Julio's Story
The El Salvador native has diabetes and nearly died in the Arizona desert. When Cuellar ran out of insulin and became sick, the smuggler who he paid to help him cross into the U.S. abandoned him. He spent two days without food or shelter before the U.S. border patrol rescued him.
What would make someone do this — especially a middle-aged man with a full-time job?
Cuellar's daughter, Guadalupe, blames herself. She was pregnant when he left and had just been diagnosed with cancer. There was no money for treatment.
"My father had so many debts already," she says. "He wanted to pay those and make life easier for us, so I could quit my job and stay home with the children."
Guadalupe's parents long ago divorced, and her father raised her. For the past few years her mom has been working — illegally — in Texas.
She says her dad's coyote — or smuggler — assured him it would be an easy trip. But for three months, she didn't hear anything, and she wondered if something went wrong or if he had died.
Then a call came from the U.S. government that Cuellar was being deported three days later.
'Never Get Ahead'
Cuellar's family — his daughter, grandson, great-nephew and sister — meet him in the airport parking lot. They've waited for hours in the hot sun, and as he emerges, they're in for a shock.
In his short time away, Cuellar has lost 40 pounds and aged visibly.
As they share long, tight hugs, the entire family breaks into loud sobs. Cuellar then cradles the 2-month-old granddaughter he is meeting for the first time.
Three hours later, the sun is almost setting in the lower-working class suburb where Cuellar and his daughter live. When they get off a bus, Guadalupe says her father is too ashamed for the neighbors to see him, so they use a dirt path behind the row of houses, then casually arrive at the front door.
The family squeezes into a living space the size of many an American walk-in closet, and Cuellar tries to explain his predicament.
For years, he says, he has gotten by on loans. In this country, Cuellar says, a paycheck alone doesn't even provide three meals a day.
Then, a few years back, he co-signed a loan for a friend. The friend disappeared, and the lender came after Cuellar.
After Guadalupe's cancer diagnosis, Cuellar says, he felt trapped and desperate, with no other option than seeking work in the U.S.
"You can kill yourself here working and never get ahead," Cuellar says.
But now that this gamble has failed, Cuellar is in worse straits.
To pay his smuggler, Cuellar gave the man the deed to his house. When Cuellar left the country, he lost his police job. And his near-death experience in the desert has left him with a host of ongoing health problems.
Cuellar swears he'll never try crossing to the U.S. again. But he still has no idea how to fix the problems that pushed him to go in the first place.
This story was produced for broadcast by Marisa Penaloza.
Comments
This story portrays well why immigrants come to the U.S., and why deportation is not an answer.Because Cuellar saw no answer to his desperate needs in El Salvador, he decided that it would be best to come to the U.S. illegaly, along with a coyote as a guide. Even working as a state policeman was not enough to help this man and his daughter get by. I would not be surprised if he tried to get back into the U.S., because he can't be treated for his health problems, and neither can his daughter.
Deportation just further exarcebates the problems that cause immigrants to return to the U.S. Not in Cuellar's case, but El Salvador has seen an increase in gang members since the number of immigrants being deported to El Salvador has increased (The Maras: Gangs of El Salvador). When immigrants are deported, if they have established a life in the U.S. or not, it is very difficult for them to assimilate back into their society socially and/or economically. They have no money, and therefore will do anything to get money, which could contribute to the unsafe conditions within a society (depending on what the person does), that will keep driving others out. Take Estella Lemus, for instance from El Salvador, who is paid $5/day, and doesn't know how she will pay back the $3,000 her family borrowed for her trip, after being deported (After deportation, migrants are determined to return).
When looking at the after effects of the mass deportation of Mexicans during the Great Depression, it is obvious the pattern that causes immigrants to come to the U.S. When the mass deportation of Mexicans occured in the U.S., in Mexico there was already a depression going on. In addition, the Mexican children who had learned english only, now had to learn spanish. Then it was also difficult for the adults who had left their families behind in the U.S., to find jobs (1930s Mexican Deportation). The same situation is going on today.
Something needs to be done so that immigrants will not be risking their lives in order to make it t the U.S., so that they will only find themselves back where they started. Just like in Cuellar's case, most immigrants just want to come and work, and then be able to return to their homes. A solution could be the guest worker program,making Non-Immigrant Visas or Work Visas easier to obtain, and keep track of. It's not the job of the U.S. to police the world, but if it doesn't want illegal immigrants shouldn't it be at least trying to help these countries so that they won't self destruct and cause further immigration of people?
Posted by: Dali | April 26, 2008 12:53 PM